I am quite fair and I love the color of this mascara - much more flattering and natural looking than the usual brown-black. It also gives a good thickness to my lashes. My only wish is that it could be made waterproof and tear proof.
Not a fan
Went on clumpy, hard to get on evenly and it irritated my eyes all day. Would not recommend. Color was good though
The best brown mascara - ever
I love this mascara! Goes on easily, no clumping or smearing. And the color!!!!! Because it has such warmth, it really brings out the color in my grey/blue eyes. A real keeper.
Reviewer: KMP Florida
Best I've tried
I love the soft brown color and that it is not gloppy and doesn't smear. Black and black/brown look too stark with my grey hair and fine eyebrows. Also, it is rated very well by EWG (low safety concerns).
I love the color and it is perfect for me but I do not care for the applicator brush! It is much too thick to work with!
Best brown mascara ever!
This is the safest & best brown mascara ever! It is a true dark brown, doesn't clump, flake or feel "crispy" and washes off easily!
I've been switching to more natural products, so I decided it was time to update the makeup. I'm blonde, so I always have trouble with mascara-Without it I look like I'm missing my lashes, with it I look like I'm going clubbing because it looks so dark. This mascara is the PERFECT shade, natural enough to be work and daily life appropriate but I now have eye lashes!! I haven't had any issues with flaking, or building up in the creases under my eyes (some brands do, this is extremely minimal and definitely no worse than any other brand). Love it, thanks for making not just a natural product but a great one!!
Love the color
I love the color of this Sable brown mascara. Most brown mascaras, when you can find them, are too dark. I'm almost 60, so I need something a little softer color around the eyes. It's smooth, creamy and lasts all day. It's also easy to remove. If I could change anything, I would ask for a little bit smaller brush. I have arthritis and I have trouble with the fuller brushes, I tend to get mascara on my eye lid and then have to remove it with a cotton swab.
Very good product
One of the few places were you can purchase a quality product in the color you need.
loved the Sable Brown, but love Black even more!
I used to use the Sable Brown, which I found to be a perfect rich color that matched my black-brown eyebrows, but then I switched to the black, and I love it even more. It's the pure, dark color that I really love. I would say the color of the brown formula has changed a little bit over the years, which makes me a little sad. The mascara is now a little thinner, and the brown isn't quite as dark, heading more toward a traditional chocolate color. :)